Yesteryear: Book Review

Yesteryear, a twist-filled novel with complicated characters, cult-like dynamics, multiple timelines, and plenty to discuss at book club.

Affiliate Disclosure: I may earn a commission from purchases made through affiliate links, at no extra cost to you. Thanks for supporting OMG! Kaya Reads!

yesteryear book cover

Author

Caro Claire Burke

Publisher

Knopf

Genre

Contemporary Fiction, Mystery, Satire

Pages

400

Format

eAudiobook

Summary From Goodreads

Natalie lives a traditional lifestyle – and her followers are sick with envy. Her charming farmhouse on her working ranch is artfully cluttered, her husband is a handsome cowboy, her homemade sourdough boules are each more beautiful than the last. So what if there are nannies and producers and industrial-grade ovens behind the scenes? What her followers don’t know won’t hurt them. Then, one morning, Natalie wakes up in a strange, horrible version of reality. Her home, her husband, her children—they’re all familiar, but something’s off. Is this a hoax? A reality show? A test from God? Natalie knows just two things for sure: this isn’t her perfect life, and she must escape, by any means possible. As darkly funny as it is shocking and gripping, Yesteryear is an electrifying examination of tradition, fame, faith and the grand performance of womanhood, from a thrilling new talent in fiction.

My Thoughts

I read Yesteryear over the summer and am just now getting around to sharing my thoughts. This book was a whirlwind! The multiple timelines, the increasingly complicated picture of Natalie, and the absolutely wild plot twist made this one a memorable read. The story moves between the present, Natalie’s childhood and upbringing, and 1854, when she is transported into the past. As the timelines came together, I found myself rethinking what I knew about Natalie and the life she had built for herself.

Natalie is a complicated character, and I had a lot of thoughts about her. She gave me strong Keep Sweet vibes, with the cultish dynamics, rigid beliefs, and idealized vision of how life should be. She seemed to be living in a gilded cage, but rather than questioning the cage itself, she became resentful of the life inside it. Natalie is a zealot, and I never really got the sense that she was interested in changing her beliefs or taking a hard look at herself. She was so committed to her own version of reality that I found myself frustrated with her, even while being fascinated by her character.

And that plot twist! It was crazy and beautifully executed. I genuinely did not see it coming, and looking back, I appreciate how the story brought everything together. I’m still surprised by why the husband stayed, especially knowing how one decision could set off a chain of events that ultimately led to what happened to Natalie. There is so much to unpack about personal responsibility, belief, control, marriage, and the stories we tell ourselves about the lives we want.

I think Yesteryear would make a great book club pick. There is so much room for discussion, especially around Natalie’s choices, whether she deserves sympathy, the role of her upbringing and beliefs, and the husband’s decisions. The multiple timelines and that twist give readers plenty to talk about, and I can imagine people having very different interpretations of the characters and their motivations. This is definitely a book I would want to discuss with other readers because I have questions, and I want to hear what everyone else took away from it.

If you enjoy psychological fiction with complicated characters, unsettling dynamics, and twists that make you rethink the story, Yesteryear is worth adding to your reading list.

popup subscription

WANT MORE?

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE THE LATEST BOOK REVIEWS & TEMPLATES, PLUS SOME CRAFTY GOODIES!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Happy Reading!

starburst

Would I recommend it?

That Plot Twist, Though!

Book Review Template Image

Make Every Book Count

Want to remember your favorite characters, capture your thoughts, or put your next book review into words?

My Book Review Template gives you a place to jot down your impressions, organize your ideas, and find just the right words to describe what you’ve read.

mint blob book lover sticker

You Might Also Enjoy

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

THE KAYA B. DESIGNS SHOP
A Little Something for Your Reading Life

Reading trackers, book review tools, journals, and printables to make your reading life a little more fun.

Book Review,black librarian,librarian,OMG Kaya Reads,OMG Kaya Reads Blog,book blogger,Cincinnati Ohio,Cincinnati blogger,Ohio blogger,reading,read,library,libraries,Vera Wong book review,Jesse Q. Sutanto,cozy mystery books,murder mystery novels,laugh out loud books,funny mystery novels,female sleuth books,older women protagonists,Glory Be similar books,humorous mysteries,contemporary cozy mysteries,book review blog,mystery book recommendations,Vera Wong series,quirky mystery novels,strong female leads,character-driven mysteries,books about friendship,unconventional detectives,witty mystery books,mystery novels for adults,engaging murder mysteries,books like Glory Be,series starter novels,entertaining mystery reads
Book Review,black librarian,librarian,OMG Kaya Reads,OMG Kaya Reads Blog,book blogger,Cincinnati Ohio,Cincinnati blogger,Ohio blogger,reading,read,library,libraries,Vera Wong book review,Jesse Q. Sutanto,cozy mystery books,murder mystery novels,laugh out loud books,funny mystery novels,female sleuth books,older women protagonists,Glory Be similar books,humorous mysteries,contemporary cozy mysteries,book review blog,mystery book recommendations,Vera Wong series,quirky mystery novels,strong female leads,character-driven mysteries,books about friendship,unconventional detectives,witty mystery books,mystery novels for adults,engaging murder mysteries,books like Glory Be,series starter novels,entertaining mystery reads
Book Review,black librarian,librarian,OMG Kaya Reads,OMG Kaya Reads Blog,book blogger,Cincinnati Ohio,Cincinnati blogger,Ohio blogger,reading,read,library,libraries,Vera Wong book review,Jesse Q. Sutanto,cozy mystery books,murder mystery novels,laugh out loud books,funny mystery novels,female sleuth books,older women protagonists,Glory Be similar books,humorous mysteries,contemporary cozy mysteries,book review blog,mystery book recommendations,Vera Wong series,quirky mystery novels,strong female leads,character-driven mysteries,books about friendship,unconventional detectives,witty mystery books,mystery novels for adults,engaging murder mysteries,books like Glory Be,series starter novels,entertaining mystery reads

More books, more thoughts.

Get book reviews, reading tips, new blog posts, and occasional freebies delivered to your inbox. Trust no spam.

Read, Watch, & Listen

Subscribe To
OMG! Kaya Reads

Get notified about new posts