I read Yesteryear over the summer and am just now getting around to sharing my thoughts. This book was a whirlwind! The multiple timelines, the increasingly complicated picture of Natalie, and the absolutely wild plot twist made this one a memorable read. The story moves between the present, Natalie’s childhood and upbringing, and 1854, when she is transported into the past. As the timelines came together, I found myself rethinking what I knew about Natalie and the life she had built for herself.
Natalie is a complicated character, and I had a lot of thoughts about her. She gave me strong Keep Sweet vibes, with the cultish dynamics, rigid beliefs, and idealized vision of how life should be. She seemed to be living in a gilded cage, but rather than questioning the cage itself, she became resentful of the life inside it. Natalie is a zealot, and I never really got the sense that she was interested in changing her beliefs or taking a hard look at herself. She was so committed to her own version of reality that I found myself frustrated with her, even while being fascinated by her character.
And that plot twist! It was crazy and beautifully executed. I genuinely did not see it coming, and looking back, I appreciate how the story brought everything together. I’m still surprised by why the husband stayed, especially knowing how one decision could set off a chain of events that ultimately led to what happened to Natalie. There is so much to unpack about personal responsibility, belief, control, marriage, and the stories we tell ourselves about the lives we want.
I think Yesteryear would make a great book club pick. There is so much room for discussion, especially around Natalie’s choices, whether she deserves sympathy, the role of her upbringing and beliefs, and the husband’s decisions. The multiple timelines and that twist give readers plenty to talk about, and I can imagine people having very different interpretations of the characters and their motivations. This is definitely a book I would want to discuss with other readers because I have questions, and I want to hear what everyone else took away from it.
If you enjoy psychological fiction with complicated characters, unsettling dynamics, and twists that make you rethink the story, Yesteryear is worth adding to your reading list.


